Laura Michet's Blog

Why I oppose self-driving vehicles

I find it very frustrating when cyclists speak well of Waymo! I don't believe these vehicles should be allowed on our streets in their current form, if ever, and I believe that we need to heavily legislate against tech company remote operation of vehicles generally.

Like many things tech companies do, the scale at which they're able to do it requires us to treat them differently than private individuals or even smaller companies.

The simplest example I can think of is "Waymo runs over a child." Usually, when a car strikes a kid, insurance companies and local police handle the incident - often very badly. Imagine, however, that someone with infinite wealth or power runs over a young person. In an incident where a car with far more lawyers and wealth than any insurance company strikes a child, I am sure that the family of that kid would not appreciate the power imbalance. Imagine having to go up against Google or Amazon to get justice for vehicular violence? In a country where killing someone with your car is already basically legal?

Long-term, there is little incentive for self-driving car companies to prioritize the safety of road users like cyclists. They can eat any amount of fine payments. They can bring any amount of legal influence to bear. It is simply not wise to allow this kind of power imbalance between road users! I think the threat of a tech company becoming a road user is, long-term, greater than the benefit of automatic driving.

It does not matter if Waymos are, today, safer for cyclists than a regular driver. Long-term, they can do pretty much anything they want, and if they obtain any amount of regulatory capture when it comes to car usage, we're boned.

We pretty much know from the UK what can happen when someone with a lot of power - and the ability to evade justice - kills someone on the road. Tech companies must be treated like state actors, like political actors - a tech company running over someone would be capable of all the same sneaky legal evasions as a national government. The police are already notorious for parking and driving irresponsibly - imagine what a tech company could accomplish, if they really wanted to? There is no barrier they cannot abuse except the barrier of a complete ban.

A collision with a Waymo is something that may very well happen to me in the future, since I ride bikes on the road. Whenever I see a Waymo, I can only think, "Oh boy. That thing is covered in cameras and has the invisible power of infinite lawyers attached to it. I would not like to get into a conflict with the owners of that car! If it runs me over my family won't get any justice!"

I think that long-term, the solution to traffic violence is not replacing cars with self-driving cars owned by powerful political actors, but rather removing them from the street environment entirely. If given the choice between "allowing the planet's most powerful and immoral entities to drive a car near me" and "not allowing cars to drive near me at all," I'd choose number 2. I support pedestrianization, or full separation of car traffic from other road users. I do not want a company with literally thousands of lawyers operating a vehicle near me at all, no matter how safe they seem to be in the year 2026.

#bicycles